Court Rejects Roko’s Defective Doors Defence, Orders Shs5.7 Billion Payment To Assa Abloy

Court Rejects Roko’s Defective Doors Defence, Orders Shs5.7 Billion Payment To Assa Abloy

By Spy Uganda

The Commercial Division of the High Court has ordered Roko Construction Company to pay Assa Abloy Uganda Limited $1.39 million (approximately Shs5.7 billion) after ruling that the construction firm failed to prove its claims that doors and accessories supplied for the renovation of Mulago National Referral Hospital were defective.

In a ruling delivered on October 16, Justice Stephen Mubiru found that Roko had accepted and installed the supplied materials but failed to pay the full contractual amount, leaving an outstanding balance of $1,391,667.58.

The decision brings a major commercial dispute over thousands of doors installed at Uganda’s largest referral hospital closer to resolution, with the court holding that Roko could not escape its payment obligations by raising complaints about the goods long after receiving and using them.

Justice Mubiru ruled that Assa Abloy had provided sufficient evidence to establish its claim and was entitled to recover the unpaid balance. The court, however, dismissed the case against the Attorney General, who had been listed as the second defendant, with costs.

The dispute arose from a series of orders for doors and ironmongery accessories intended for Mulago Hospital during its major renovation programme.

Court records show that Roko initially placed an order on June 30, 2017, for 2,398 steel door sets valued at $1.57 million. The consignment included steel frames, wooden door leaves, transom panels and fixing accessories manufactured and shipped from Assa Abloy’s factory in Dubai, United Arab Emirates.

The order was later revised to cover 2,716 doors and accessories, raising its value to $2.22 million.

On January 18, 2019, Roko placed an additional order for assorted ironmongery worth $365,342.97, bringing the combined value of the orders to $2,581,667.58.

The materials were delivered and installed at Mulago Hospital between August 31, 2017, and October 31, 2018. Under the agreement, payment was due within 45 days of delivery.

However, Roko paid only $1.19 million, leaving Assa Abloy with an outstanding claim of $1.39 million that eventually ended up before the courts.

In its defence, Roko argued that some of the supplied doors and accessories were defective or did not meet the agreed specifications. The company also relied on claims that part of the consignment had been returned or repossessed in disputing the amount it owed.

Justice Mubiru rejected the defence, pointing to the construction firm’s failure to formally communicate its rejection of the allegedly defective materials within a reasonable period.

The judge observed that Roko had retained and installed the doors for years without notifying Assa Abloy that it was rejecting them on grounds of quality or non-compliance.

“In conclusion, had the 1st defendant genuinely wished to reject any doors, it was required to intimate this rejection to the plaintiff within a reasonable time. It did not do so. Therefore, the 1st defendant’s defence of defective or non-compliant goods is not available,” Justice Mubiru held.

The court found that Roko’s conduct amounted to acceptance of the supplied goods, weakening its attempt to use the alleged defects as a basis for avoiding payment.

The dispute over whether hundreds of doors had been returned or repossessed also failed to convince the court.

Justice Mubiru noted that evidence presented during the proceedings showed that the doors had been installed across Mulago Hospital Blocks A through K.

He further cited an August 2020 joint audit that confirmed the installation of all 2,716 doors.

“The doors were installed at Mulago Hospital. D.W.1 testified to the installation process across Blocks ‘A’ through ‘K’. The August 2020 joint audit confirmed 2,716 doors installed,” the judge observed.

The court added that neither party had produced evidence establishing that 1,358 doors had actually been removed from the hospital premises, leaving the alleged repossession without sufficient factual support.

The ruling reinforces the importance of timely communication in commercial supply contracts, particularly where a buyer intends to reject goods on grounds of defects or failure to meet agreed specifications.

For Assa Abloy, the judgment provides a legal basis to recover the unpaid contractual balance after years of dispute over materials supplied for a major public health infrastructure project.

For Roko, the decision means that its objections over the quality and alleged return of the goods did not relieve it of the obligation to pay for the consignment the court found had been delivered and installed.

The court’s order specifically directs Roko to pay the outstanding $1,391,667.58 to Assa Abloy Uganda Limited, while the Attorney General was cleared of liability in the suit.

Related Post